Any soda will work--I choose Coca Cola (recently in science camp we observed that dark soda produced a higher geyser) and orange soda (Bam's favorite color). I was told by the teacher that only mint mentos work. We didn't use a whole package of mentos per bottle. I used about 8 for the Coca Cola experiment and Bam used 3 mentos. You really have to drop the candy in quickly otherwise you get covered in sticky soda.
My husband was so impressed and surprised by the Coca Cola experiment that he forgot to take pictures. We didn't tell him what was going to happen. Here is the start of the orange soda geyser.
Bam and Bob running through the sprinklers afterwards. More fun than tanking a bath after this sticky experiment.